Experimental Investigation of Thermal and Hydraulic Characteristics of Finned Flat Tubes of the Oil Air Cooling Device

Air cooling devices are heat exchange units that are widely used in practice. However, they have a number of disadvantages due to the low value of the heat transfer coefficient from the air and the high resistance of finned tube bundles, which leads to large dimensions and the metal content of the device itself, to the need to develop a high power ventilator drive, but also to the need to demonstrate reduced energy efficiency. The objective of the present work is to determine optimal geometric sizes of finned flat heat exchange tubes manufactured by the techniques of extrusion and deforming cutting that reduce the weight and size characteristics of the heat exchange section of air cooling devices. The experimental studies of seven various samples of heat exchange sections, being different in fin pitch and height, tube section width, flat tube height and a number of inner channels, have determined the performance of each section with the use of the following criteria: thermal power, thermal efficiency, specific thermal heat transfer resistance, M. V. Kirpichev and V. M. Antuf’ev’s criteria. The obtained experimental data and the analysis of the passive method of enhancement in the near-wall area of the heat transfer surface finned by deforming cutting has shown that sample No 5 has maximum value of the performance criteria when the maximum height of a fin is 0.008 m and the minimum pitch of a fin is 0.0025 m over the investigated sample range. Thus, when the sizes of an oil air cooling device are maintained by using the amended heat transfer section of sample No 5, the amount of removed heat can be increased or the mass and dimensions of the device can be decreased while maintaining thermal power and, as a result, the power consumption for pumping can be decreased and the thermal-hydraulic performance of the device as a whole can be increased.

1. Shmerkovich V. M. (1971) Air Cooling Apparatuses Implementation in Design of Refineries and Petrochemical Plants. Мoscow; CRIITERpetrochem. 112 (in Russian).

2. Bessonnyi A. N.; Dreitser G. A.; Kuntysh V. B. et al. (1996) Fundamentals of Calculation and Design of Air Cooling Heat Exchangers. Saint-Petersburg; Nedra Publ. 512 (in Russian).

3. Sidyagin A. A.; Kosyrev V. M. Calculation and Design of Air Cooling Devices. Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod State Technical University n. a. R. E. Alekseev. 150 (in Russian).

4. Mil'man O. O.; Federov V. A.; Lavrov V. I.; Demochkin V. A.; Gerasimov A. V.; Serezhkin N. I.; Khochkin I. A. (1998) Air Condensers for Steam Turbine Units of Low and Medium Power. Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering; (1); 35−39 (in Russian).

5. Korolev I. I.; Genova E. V.; Benklyan S. E. (1996) On Cooling Systems of Combined Heat and Power Plants. Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering; (11); 49–55 (in Russian).

6. Mil’man O. O.; Fedorov V. A. (2002) Air-Condensing Installations. Moscow; MEI Publ. 208 (in Russian).

7. Yanqiang Kong; Weijia Wang; Zhitao Zuo; Lijun Yang; Xiaoze Du; Yongping Yang (2019) Combined Air-Cooled Condenser Layout with in Line Configured Finned Tube Bundles to Improve Cooling Performance. Applied Thermal Engineering; 154; 505–518. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2019.03.099.

8. Kong Y. Q.; Yang L. J.; Du X. Z.; Yang Y. P. (2016) Impacts of Geometric Structures on Thermo-Flow Performances of Plate Fin-Tube Bundles. International Journal of Thermal Sciences; 107; 161–178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijthermalsci.2016.04.011.

9. Gusev V. M.; Kovalev N. I.; Popov V. P.; Potroshkov V. A. (1981) Heat Engineering; Heating; Ventilation and Air Conditioning. Leningrad; Stroiizdat Publ. 343 (in Russian).

10. Zorin V. M. (2012) Nuclear Power Plants. Moscow; MEI Publishing House. 672 (in Russian).

11. Vasil'ev V. A.; Il'enko V. V. Development of a Pilot Modular Power Plant for the European Area of Russia. Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering; (4); 30–33 (in Russian).

12. Kuntysh V. B.; Sukhotskii A. B.; Samorodov A. V. (2014) Engineering Method for Thermal Analysis of an Air Cooler in a Regime of Free-Convective Heat Exchange. Chemical and Petroleum Engineering; 49 (11–12); 773–779. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10556-014-9834-9.

13. Popov I. A.; Gortyshov Yu. F.; Olimpiev V. V. (2012) Industrial Application of Heat Transfer Intensification: Current State of the Problem (a Review). Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering; (1); 3–14 (in Russian).

14. Kalinin A. F.; Fomin A. V. (2011) Evaluation of the Performance of the Ventilators of New Generation for the “2AVG-75” Air Cooler. Neft'; Gaz i Biznes [Oil; Gas and Business]; (2); 57–60 (in Russian).

15. Vasil'ev Yu. N.; Gritsenko A. I.; Nesterov V. I. (1992) Improving the Efficiency of Heat Exchangers. Neftyanoe Khozyaistvo = Oil Industry; (5); 93–95 (in Russian).

16. Kuntysh V. B.; Bessonnyi A. N.; Brill' A. A. (1997) Improving the Energy Efficiency of Air-Cooled Heat Exchangers. Chemical and Petroleum Engineering; 33 (4); 402–407. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02416728.

17. Shaikhutdinov A. Z.; Lifanov V. A.; Malanichev V. A. (2010) Modern Devices of Air Cooling of Gas as a Resource of Energy Saving in Gas Industry. Gazovaya Promyshlennost' = Gas Industry Magazine; (9); 40–41 (in Russian).

18. Aksenov P. A.; Dashunin N. V.; Zabrodin Yu. V.; Lifanov V. A.; Malanichev V. A.; Miatov O. L. (2003) Air Cooling Devices of the New Generation. The Optimal Combination of Parameters of the Heat Exchange Unit and Ventilator Installation. Neftegaz; (2); 109–111 (in Russian).

19. Davletov K. M. et al. (2006) Physical Model and General Mathematical Formulation of the Problem of Investigation of Thermal and Aerodynamic Characteristics of the Air Cooling Apparatus with External Air Recirculation in the Modes of Louver Regulation. Geologiya; Burenie; Razrabotka i Ekspluatatsiya Gazovykh i Gazokondensatnykh Mestorozhdenii: NauchnoTekhnicheskii Sbornik [Geology; Drilling; Development and Operation of Gas and Gas Condensate Fields: Scientific and Technical Collection]. Moscow; Gazprom; (4); 53–56 (in Russian).

20. Astaf'ev E. N.; Davletov K. M.; Ignat'ev M. P. (2006) Analysis of the Choice of Options for the Configuration of Air Cooling Devices of Booster Compressor Stations in the Deposit Development of in the Far North. Nauka i Tekhnika v Gazovoi Promyshlennosti [Science and Technology in the Gas Industry]; (4); 42–48 (in Russian).

21. Aksyutin O. E. (2009) Reduction of Energy Consumption for Natural Gas Cooling in Air Cooling Devices of the Compressor Station. Gazovaya Promyshlennost' = Gas Industry Magazine; (2); 74–76 (in Russian).

22. Arshakyan I. I. (2006) Improving the Efficiency of Gas Cooling Plants. Gazovaya Promyshlennost' = Gas Industry Magazine; (12); 52–55 (in Russian).

23. State Standart 15150–69. Machines; Devices and Other Technical Products. Modifications for Different Climatic Regions. Categories; Conditions of Operation; Storage and Transportation in Terms of the Impact of Climatic Factors of the Environment. Moscow; Standartinform; 2006. 60 (in Russian).

24. Kuntysh V. B.; Piir A. E. (2009) Analysis of the Thermal Efficiency; Volume; and Weight Characteristics of Heat Exchange Sections of Air Cooling Equipment. Chemical and Petroleum Engineering; 45 (5–6); 257–262. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10556-009-9183-2.

25. Popov I. A.; Yakovlev A.; Shchelchkov A.; Ryzhkov A. V. (2011) Promising Methods of Heat Exchange Intensification for Heat Power Equipment. Energetika Tatarstana [Power Engineering of Tatarstan]; 1; 25–29 (in Russian).

26. Olimpiev V. V. (2010) Enhancement of Heat Transfer and the Potential for Energy Conservation in Industrial Oil Coolers. Thermal Engineering; 57 (8); 702–713. https://doi.org/10.1134/s0040601510080148.

27. Brodov Yu. M.; Aronson K. E.; Ryabchikov A. Yu.; Bukhman G. D. (1994) Development and Pilot Testing of a Set of Measures to Improve the Efficiency and Reliability of Oil Coolers. Elektricheskie Stantsii = Electrical Stations; (12); 33–36 (in Russian).

28. Pis'mennyi E. N.; Demchenko V. G.; Terekh A. M.; Semenyako A. V. (2010) Economizer and the Heat Exchanger of the Flat Oval Tubes with Partial Ribbing. Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies; 3/1 (45); 15–19 (in Russian).

29. Osipov S. N.; Zakharenko A. V. (2018) Energy-Efficient Compact Heat Exchangers Made of Porous Heat-Conducting Materials. Energetika. Izvestiya Vysshikh Uchebnykh Zavedenii i Energeticheskikh Ob’edinenii SNG = Energetika. Proceedings of the CIS Higher Education Institutions and Power Engineering Associations; 61 (4); 346–358. https://doi.org/10.21122/1029-7448-2018-61-4-346-358.

30. Zubkov N. N.; Ovchinnikov A. I.; Kononov O. V. (1993) Fabrication of Heat Exchange Surfaces of a New Class by Deforming Cutting. Vestnik MGTU imеni N. E. Baumana. Ser. “Mashinostroenie” = Herald of the Bauman Moscow State Technical University. Series Mechanical Engineering; (4); 79–82 (in Russian).

31. Skrypnik A. N.; Shchelchkov A. V.; Popov I. A.; Ryzhkov D. V.; Sverchkov S. A.; Zhukova Yu. V.; Chornyi A. D.; Zubkov N. N. (2018) Thermohydraulic Efficiency of Pipes with Internal Spiral Fins. Journal of Engineering Physics and Thermophysics; 91 (1); 52–63. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10891-018-1718-y.